Showing posts with label Incentives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Incentives. Show all posts

Monday, January 19, 2015

NITI AYOG




Introduction

     The “Yojna Aayog” or “Planning Commission” has been replaced by the “National Institution for Transforming India” or “NITI” for short.  From “Yojana” to “Niti” what is the difference?  First and foremost a sharp break from Soviet inspired National Development (Five Year) Plans to “Niti”, that is “Policy” and Institutional change for ‘transforming India’.  Para three of the cabinet resolution states that, we “require institutional reforms in governance and dynamic policy shifts that can seed and nurture large-scale change.”

Policy And Institutions

“Development” is one of those words that everyone thinks they understand but means many different things to different people. It covers a multitude of possibilities as well as a multitude of ideological sins and special agendas. The cabinet resolution constituting the Niti Aayog approvingly quotes Mahatma Gandhi “Constant development is the law of life, and a man who always tries to maintain his dogmas in order to appear consistent drives himself into a false position”. The Planning Commission took its first tentative steps towards “policy” 28 years ago, by creating a post of Advisor Development Policy. There was so much resistance, that the Advisor (yours truly) had to be designated Advisor-Development Policy Research.” Despite decades of effort, policy solutions always played second fiddle to increasing Plan allocations and expenditures without any ‘social benefit-cost analysis’ or ‘Macro-economic models’ to back the decisions.[i]
   Three other points in the introductory part of the Cabinet resolution setting up Niti Aayog are noteworthy: First is the assertion that “our aspirations have soared and today we seek elimination, rather than alleviation, of poverty” The second is the important role given to governance in achieving desirable social outcomes:  “The people of India have great expectations for progress and improvement in governance, through their participation. They require institutional reforms in governance and dynamic policy shifts that can seed and nurture large-scale change (para 3).” Subsequently there is an indication of how the institutional reforms in governance can be brought about: “Government and governance have to be conducted in an environment of total transparency – using technology to reduce opacity and thereby, the potential for misadventures in governing(para 6 g).”
   An EPW (2002) paper had raised the issue of corruption & governance and to bring policy-institutional reform into the development debate, to no avail.[ii] A debate on Poverty elimination, as against alleviation, was sought to be initiated in 2005-06 through a Planning Commission paper, but was stymied.[iii] It is therefore very encouraging that this is an important part of the mandate of the Niti Aayog.
Third, is the recognition of a changed reality of economy, society and Government functioning and its implications: “India needs an administration paradigm in which the government is an “enabler” rather than a “provider of first and last resort”. The role of the government as a “player” in the industrial and service sectors has to be reduced. Instead, government has to focus on enabling legislation, policy making and regulation (para 6a)” Many old style development planners refused to accept these changes ( even if they paid lip service to it), though this issue was raised first in 1990s & subsequently in the 2000s.[iv] A recognition of this reality by the Union cabinet provides a sound basis for closing the technology gap between India and Advanced countries, that is correlated with the large income gap between us. The reference to the role of Urbanization (para 6g) as an aid to technological catch-up, suggests an understanding of the links between technology gaps and per capita income gaps. This further links to Welfare gaps through the statement, “Equality of opportunity goes hand in hand with an inclusiveness agenda(para 8c).” The open discussion of the global environment and its two way interaction with India, also displays a degree of self-confidence vis-à-vis foreign countries (para 6c) that bodes well for building a competitive fast growing economy.

Niti Aayog

So what is the specific role of Niti Aayog in this changed environment: Its primary/central role is to, “Serve as a Think Tank for the Government”.. “to give “strategic and technical advice across the spectrum of key elements of policy. This includes matters of national and international import on the economic front, dissemination of best practices from within the country as well as from other nations, the infusion of new policy ideas and specific issue-based support.” (para 11). Several of us have argued for a long time, without much success, that the Old Planning Commission should evolve into a “Think Tank” with a primary emphasis on policy and institutions, rather than on expenditure programs and projects. By its bold move to abolish the Yojna Aayog and set up the Niti Aayog the new Government has set the stage for a wholesale transformation in this direction. Given the absence of any formal social benefit-cost analysis of programs and projects and the limited capacity for appraisal of outcomes, one had also suggested to the Deputy Chairman a decade ago that the Planning Commission develop a data base of best practices to guide future decisions.  It is hoped that a full fledged division will be set up in the Niti Aayog to translate this into reality, with all such information digitally accessible to experts and policy makers.
   Some of the specific objectives of the Niti Aayog are, at the level of generality of the Cabinet note, not significantly different from those of the Planning Commission or other organs of Government. However, the following objectives suggest a greater priority and emphasis on the issues mentioned in them: 
  1)    To design strategic and long term policy and programme frameworks and initiatives, and monitor their progress and their efficacy. The lessons learnt through monitoring and feedback will be used for making innovative improvements, including necessary mid-course corrections
   2)    To provide advice and encourage partnerships between key stakeholders and national and international like minded Think Tanks, as well as educational and policy research institutions
   3)    To create a knowledge, innovation and entrepreneurial support system through a collaborative community of national and international experts, practitioners and other partners
   4)    To maintain a state-of-the-art Resource Centre, be a repository of research on good governance and best practices in sustainable and equitable development as well as help their dissemination to stake-holders
   5)    To focus on technology up gradation and capacity building for implementation of programs and initiatives
      In the first of these, the emphasis on “lessons learnt” is very important. Experience confirms a great reluctance to modify or junk programs when they don’t work. Vested build up and become so strong that it becomes impossible to overcome them.
 In the second the emphasis on interaction with international think tanks and Indian educational and policy research institutions, though expected from a ‘Think Tank for the government,’ would be a departure for Indian bureaucracy.
In the third, the emphasis on support systems, rather than funds/subsidies is an important departure.
    The fourth reinforces what was said earlier about good governance and best practices and suggests that improvement in governance will be seriously pursued to improve delivery of government social & welfare programs.
In the fifth the recognition of weak capacity and need for “capacity building” for implementation is critical to success of all new initiatives and many failed/failing old ones. For instance Urban development won’t work properly, unless we train hundreds of Urban planners. Similarly, setting up of traditional “Bric and Mortar” educational institutions (as against e-learning/education) will be quite ineffective unless we have scores of highly trained professors.

Conclusion

   The abolition of the Yojana Aayog and its replacement by the Niti Aayog, by the new government, is a bold and long overdue initiative.[v]  It will help change the emphasis from Projects and programs to Policy and institutions, from expenditure inputs to real outcomes through better governance and from political disputation over Incremental allocations to new challenges and opportunities in a global environment. The discussion of India in a global context also reminds one of Gandhi ji’s saying, “Let the windows of my mind be open to winds from across the World, but let me not be blown away by them.” Like all new institutions, it will be an extremely challenging job for Niti Aayog to fulfill its high objectives.
--------------------------------
A version of this article appeared on the OpEd page of The Hindu of 18th January 2015, under the banner,” The New Name of Planning”: http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/niti-aayog-the-new-name-of-planning/article6799483.ece


[i] When I first arrived at the Planning Commission I was shocked to find no sign of “Social Cost-Benefit analysis” (as against Economic appraisal/cost-benefit analysis), the original justification & Sina-Qua-non of “Project appraisal”. The “models” that were sometimes said to be used in Planning Commission were of US undergraduate level.  In 2000s we did commission 3-4 Indian think tanks to build macro/CGE models suitable for policy analysis, but these were quite separate from five year or annual expenditure allocations, which were done by traditional methods.  
[ii] Arvind Virmani, “A New Development Paradigm: Employment, Entitlement and Empowerment,” Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. XXXVII No. 22, June 1-7, 2002, pp. 2145-2154. https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=sites&srcid=ZGVmYXVsdGRvbWFpbnxkcmFydmluZHZpcm1hbml8Z3g6MjQ4ODc3YWI2ZDcxZmE5NQ .
[iii] Arvind Virmani, “Poverty And Hunger In India: What is needed To Eliminate Them,” Working Paper No. 1/2006-PC, Planning Commission, February 2006.
[iv]  Arvind Virmani, “Size and Role of Government: Quality vs. Quantity of Intervention”, Indian Economic Journal,  Vol. 37, No. 4, April-June 1990; and Virmani(2002) op cit
[v] See, http://dravirmani.blogspot.in/2014/08/bharatiya-vikas-niti-sansthan-bvns.html for more on what will happen to planning and what  “Niti Ayog” may do in future.

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

TOWARDS A NEW PARADIGM



Overview


Any new approach must correct the incentives for productivity and create disincentives for corruption.  It has long been said that Democracy is the worst form of government except all the others. The greatest advantage of a market economy is that it is based on the most realistic assumption that every individual will act in his/her best interest.  Economic theory also tells us that under certain conditions market competition produces results that are the most efficient.   As the obverse of monopoly it is a useful goal even when the ideal is not attainable. It has therefore come to be widely accepted over the last two decades that market incentives are the most sustainable incentives for business, workers and farmers and that market competition is the best handmaiden of the social purpose. The best antidote to exploitation by corrupt businessmen & bureaucrats, lazy organised sector workers and shoddy products and services is competition.
Competition is also the best means of dispersing economic power.[1]  In an ideal system (Schumpeterian) competition would ensure that wealth could only be garnered through innovation, acquisition of special skills, hard work and thrift.  Such wealth generation is therefore in the interests of the entire society.  Monopoly (or oligopoly) is the anti-thesis of such competition as it allows generation of profits without any such meritorious activity.  Government created monopolies, whether deliberately created or the indirect result of distorting policies, are the worst culprits in this regard.  ‘Natural’ monopolies have to be regulated to ensure that ‘monopoly profits’ are minimised. 
Ideal competition is just that and market incentives are not perfect.  There will be market failure and non-existence of markets.  Market economics itself help identify, analyse and suggest the best way of dealing with such problems; Appropriate policies, developmental actions and regulatory institutions.
The second underlying problem can only be addressed by the dispersal of the government’s enormous power.  This requires right sizing of government, shedding of activities that can be performed by others, decentralisation of governmental functions to lower levels based on the principle of subsidiarity, the creation of countervailing power, transfer of regulatory functions to independent professional regulators, empowerment of citizens and civic groups, giving voice to the under-employed and creation of checks and balances.

Incentives Efficiency & Productivity

Law & Incentives

            Laws, particularly economic laws (including contract law), do not merely define what a citizen/resident can or cannot do.  They create a system of incentives and dis-incentives for economic agents and those charged with implementing the law.  Most economic laws have had consequences that the originators had no inkling off.  The common result of the myriad such laws are to create incentives for rent seeking, rent creation, bribery and corruption.  The rules & procedures for public institutions, such as universities, research institutions, and hospitals, are equally oppressive.
Recent studies have demonstrated the (static) costs imposed on producers by the bureaucratic red tape and harassment that results from oppressive rules and procedures.  The dynamic costs, in terms of discouragement of creative, innovative & knowledgeable people from entering business, though much harder to measure may be more devastating in the long run. It is necessary to systematically audit all economic laws from the incentive perspective and modernise them keeping in mind the results that they have produced.  Laws, rules and procedures must be modified to minimise the time & money cost of compliance to relatively honest economic agents.
Labour laws, though made with the best intentions have in many instances had the opposite of the intended affect.  Labour laws that focus on health and safety of the workers are essential and should be extended to unorganised workers.  Similarly the right of assembly, formation of labour and right to strike are democratic rights of workers.  Harmful laws are those that try to overturn market demand, supply and pricing principles, such as elements of the contract labour act Industrial development and regulation act and the Industrial disputes act.  These elements of laws by protecting existing organised sector workers provide an incentive for them not to work sincerely & efficiently and also provide a dis-incentive to hire new workers.  They need to be made more flexible so that organised labour-intensive manufacturing & services are encouraged to generate higher productivity jobs.

Competition & Efficiency

The same basic principles of competition apply to infrastructure services and factor markets as to the goods market.  De-control and de-licensing must be completed in the remaining items such as drugs, fertilisers, coal, petroleum, sugar and small industry. SSI reservation is perhaps one of two main reasons why India, unlike China, has not become the ‘manufacturing base’ for the world supply of labour intensive goods.  Lacs of new jobs have been lost in exportable industries in a futile attempt to preserve the profits of existing small-scale industrialists.
Similarly the key issue for a sick consumer is whether the drug is genuine and will cure the sickness that it claims do, or whether it is one of the myriads of spurious drugs that are flooding the market.  The price is a secondary consideration, and the governments health programs are the appropriate channels for insuring that poor patients have access to basic drugs at an affordable price.   
De-control and de-licensing must also be extended to services, including infrastructure services (e.g. telecom) and factor markets (labour & management).  Contrary to some assertions, the same principles apply to infrastructure service, with the addition of measures to unbundled and regulate natural monopoly segments.

State Monopolies

State monopolies, whether they are departmental public enterprises or Public sector units, have proved to be as inefficient and antithetical to consumers/public interest as private monopolies.  Such monopolies not only invite extraction of monopoly rents and X-inefficiency but also confer additional power on government departments & their ministers that is easy to misuse.  Introduction of competition and dispersal of this power requires, free private entry, un-bundling of all natural monopoly elements and their regulation by independent regulators, and privatisation of all contestable elements (core & non-core) so as to introduce genuine competition into the latter. Public sector & nationalised banks also constitute a near-monopoly as around 80% of the entire banking system is owned by the government.  This is the highest percentage in the world.  As we already have one of the better regulatory systems (RBI) and banking has no natural monopoly elements, the banking system will only become competitive if these are privatised.

Extract from, "A New Development Paradigm: Employment, Entitlement and Empowerment,"  Economic and Political Weekly, Vol.XXXVII No. 22, June 1-7, 2002 [ NewParadigm4nf ]


[1] A credible “Threat of competition,” for instance through potential imports, is an even more powerful incentive for change than actual competition/imports.